Skip to main

Painesville Pet Store | Pet Supplies Plus

Shop this Store

HOURS

Sun: 10:00 AM - 06:00 PM

Mon-Sat: 09:00 AM - 09:00 PM

ADDRESS

Pet Supplies Plus

1213 Mentor Avenue

Painesville, OH 44077-1833

sliderImage
shop cat month deals

About this Store

Our store has been open since 2015, happily serving the Painesville community. We are located on Mentor Avenue, conveniently in the Giant Eagle plaza. Our VIP PetCare Clinic opened in 2020; however, they are currently closed every other Saturday. Call us for their schedule! We have a grooming salon full of wonderful groomers. They love to give your pups the spa day they deserve! Make sure to book an appointment or talk with one of the groomers to see what would be best for your pup! Our Store Team Leader, Marcus, has a cavapoo named Izzy (the princess of the household), a sharpei/rottie mix named Annie (the royal guardian) and a pit/sharpei/velociraptor mix named Zoey (who acts like the jester of the group). As if that wasn't enough, there is the leader of the cavalry guard, Lacey, our paint pony. Our Assistant Store Lead, Sam, has many animals ranging from lizards to guinea pig to a dog. Her dog makes frequent stops in our store and we have even made a nickname for him as "Beef tip" She is probably our biggest animal lover here. She use to take care of all the animals in our building and her hard work and dedication have led her to a promotion!

Services:

Dog Wash

Dog Wash

Self-service dog wash - Everything you need to wash and dry your dog

Self-Serve Dog Wash
Deliver From Store

Deliver from Store

Shop online and have your local store deliver it right to your door.

Deliver from Store
Autoship

Autoship

Get 35% off your first order. Stay enrolled and receive sale pricing, plus an additional 5% off all future orders. Availability may vary.

Autoship
Bakery

Bakery

Treat them to Drool-worthy delights from the bakery case.

Bakery
Flexible Plastic Pet Food & Treat Bags Recycling Program

Recycling Program

We accept recycling of all flexible plastic pet food & treat bags, from ALL brands, across ALL species, purchased from ANY retailer.

Recycling Program
Dog Grooming

Grooming

Regular grooming keeps your pets looking good and is important to maintaining their good health

Grooming
Live Fish

Live Fish

Beautiful Bettas, Dazzling Danios, Gorgeous Glofish and even MORE in Store! Selection Varies by location.

Live Small Pets

Live Small Pets

Stop in to find your new feathery friend, cuddly companion or scaly sidekick! Species selection varies by location.

Small Pet Live Crickets

Live Crickets

Our in-store crickets make sure your critter always has the nutrition they need!

Visiting-Pet-Care-Clinic

Visiting Pet Care Clinic

Low cost preventative veterinary care, hours and services vary by location. No appointment necessary.

Veterinary Clinics
Buy-Online-Pickup-in-Store

Curbside Pickup

Buy online and pick up when it is convenient for you. Come on in, or we will bring it to your car. It is easy, fast and best of all free!

Curbside Pickup

Events & Specials

Sun - May 4, 2025

1:00 PM - 3:00 PM

In-Store Event

CInco de MEOW! Come celebrate and save! Stop by with your purr baby for mucho fun during our feline fiesta. Dr. Marty swag and samples, Fussie Cat samples and get entered to win free Dr. Elseys litter for 1 year.

Sat - Jun 14, 2025

12:00 PM - 2:00 PM

In-Store Event

Join our Small Pet Fest! From hamsters to guinea pigs to ferrets and rabbits this party is for you. Learn about hay and pet health. Special savings on Oxbow and Marshalls

Meet the Team

(and their pets)

memberImage

Abby Bevione

Shift Supervisor

memberImage

Danielle Johnson

Groomer

memberImage

Jordan Stemple

Shift Supervisor

memberImage

Makayla Langford

Assistant Store Team Lead

memberImage

Samantha Pruey

Store Team Lead

memberImage

Sammy Smith

Shift Supervisor

memberImage

Shy Ross

Groomer

Need Help?

Get more info about your Pet Supplies Plus questions.

FAQs

Get answers right away by reading our FAQs.

CALL

Contact your local store for assistance.

Email Us

Fill out a short form and we'll get back to you!